Kate Middleton
Kate Middleton

A professional lipreader claims Catherine, Princess of Wales, intervened during a tense public appearance in 2022 to caution Prince William and Prince Harry amid a visible disagreement between the brothers, a resurfaced claim that comes as the two siblings reportedly remain estranged with little indication of an imminent reconciliation.

According to lipreading specialist Nicola Hickling, who analyzed silent footage of the interaction for the Channel 5 program "Lip-Reading The Royals," Catherine appeared to instruct the brothers to "stop arguing" during a royal walkabout at Windsor Castle. The moment reportedly unfolded just two days after the death of Queen Elizabeth II, during a period when the royal family made a series of public appearances together to greet mourners outside the castle.

Hickling's analysis suggested that Prince William then turned to his wife and said, "Let's move," seemingly seeking to defuse the tension and continue with the walkabout. The specialist also claimed that Meghan Markle, Duchess of Sussex, sensed the strain between the brothers, allegedly telling them, "Not today," in an apparent effort to encourage the group to set aside their differences for the public event.

The 2022 appearance took place shortly after the queen's death, when William, Harry, Catherine and Meghan briefly reunited in public as what had previously been dubbed the "fab four," a nickname used during an earlier period when the two couples were seen as the most prominent younger members of the royal family carrying out joint engagements. That earlier era of unity had already given way to visible strain by the time of the 2022 appearance, with the brothers' relationship having deteriorated significantly in the years prior.

Roots of the rift trace back to 2018

Tensions between William and Harry are widely reported to have first emerged around the time Harry began his relationship with Meghan Markle. William reportedly voiced concerns to his brother about the pace at which the relationship was progressing ahead of Harry and Meghan's 2018 wedding, according to earlier reporting cited by The Independent.

The relationship between the brothers deteriorated further following Harry and Meghan's widely watched 2021 interview with Oprah Winfrey, in which the couple made a series of allegations about their treatment within the royal family. The rift deepened again after the 2023 release of Harry's memoir, "Spare," which included numerous claims about internal royal family dynamics that drew significant public attention and reportedly strained relations even further.

Harry's recent efforts toward reconciliation

Despite the yearslong estrangement, Prince Harry has spoken publicly about his desire to repair his relationship with his family. During a BBC interview in May 2025, Harry said any path toward reconciliation would ultimately depend on his relatives' willingness to engage, adding that if they did not want that, the decision would be entirely up to them.

Those comments have taken on renewed significance following a recent visit Harry made to the United Kingdom this month. The Duke of Sussex spent five days in the country, during which he met privately with his father, King Charles III. Harry traveled to Highgrove House, the royal family's estate in Gloucestershire, where he was received by the king and Queen Camilla.

Notably, no meeting between Harry and his brother took place during the visit, according to reports, suggesting that whatever progress may have been made in Harry's relationship with his father has not yet extended to a similar thaw with William. The absence of any reported contact between the brothers during the trip has fueled continued speculation among royal watchers about whether the two will reconcile in the near future.

A relationship watched closely by the public

The brothers' fractured relationship has remained a subject of intense public interest since their public roles diverged following Harry and Meghan's 2020 decision to step back from official royal duties and relocate to the United States. Public appearances that once featured the two couples working closely together, including the widely covered 2018 wedding and joint engagements in the years that followed, have since given way to separate public schedules and limited direct contact between the brothers.

While claims based on lipreading analysis are inherently interpretive and cannot be independently verified with certainty, the resurfaced 2022 moment has added another data point to ongoing public speculation about the state of the relationship between William and Harry. Royal commentators have continued to debate whether any reconciliation between the brothers is likely in the near term, particularly given the absence of a direct meeting during Harry's most recent visit to the UK.

For now, representatives for the royal family have not offered detailed public comment on the specific interaction described by Hickling's analysis, and the full context of the 2022 exchange between the brothers has not been independently confirmed beyond the lipreading interpretation offered on the Channel 5 program. Observers say any definitive signal of reconciliation between William and Harry would likely come through a joint public appearance or direct communication, neither of which has been reported since tensions between the brothers became public in the years following Harry and Meghan's departure from official royal duties.

Read more